
What changed (Nov 14, 2026): Added a free employee review template (DOCX, PDF, TXT) and a completed example, review types, role versions, 40+ questions and a comment bank by competency; condensed the process to 7 steps with a scoring example; merged three duplicate employee review posts into this page.
An employee review template is a standard form a manager uses to rate an employee's work over a set period, record the evidence behind each rating, and agree on goals for the next period. A good one has seven parts: employee details, a rating scale, last period's goals, competencies, a self-review, a manager summary, and next period's goals with a development plan.
This page gives you a free employee review template in Word, PDF and plain text, a fully completed example, versions for each review type, 40+ review questions, comment examples by competency, and a seven-step process for writing fair reviews. It is written for managers, founders and HR teams who need one form that works across roles.
This is HR workflow guidance, not legal advice. Pay, promotion, termination and recordkeeping decisions should follow your company policy and local employment law.
| Section | What to write | Example |
|---|---|---|
| Employee details | Name, title, team, reviewer, review type, period | Mid-year, 2026-01-01 to 2026-06-30 |
| Rating scale | Five levels with a one-line definition each | 3 = Meets: reliably delivers what the role requires |
| Goals from last period | Each agreed goal, the result with numbers, a rating | CSAT 94.1% vs 92% target: 4 |
| Competencies | 5 to 8 skills or behaviors, each with dated evidence | Collaboration: trained two new hires in May: 5 |
| Self-review | The employee's wins, challenges, support needed, proposed goals | "I need protected time for writing" |
| Manager summary | 2 to 3 strengths, 1 to 2 growth areas, overall rating and how it was reached | Weighted 3.52, banded to 4 |
| Next goals and development | Measurable goals with check-in dates, one development action, signatures | Ship 3 articles by 08-15 |
Copy the template below into a doc, or download it: employee review template (DOCX), printable employee review form (PDF), or plain text (TXT). The PDF includes the completed example from the next section on its last pages.
EMPLOYEE REVIEW
Employee: [full name] Job title: [title]
Department: [team] Reviewer: [manager name, title]
Review type: [annual / mid-year / quarterly / 90-day / project]
Review period: [YYYY-MM-DD] to [YYYY-MM-DD] Meeting date: [YYYY-MM-DD]
RATING SCALE
5 Exceptional: consistently exceeds the standard; others learn from this work
4 Exceeds: often goes beyond what the role requires
3 Meets: reliably delivers what the role requires
2 Developing: meets some expectations; needs support in named areas
1 Below: does not yet meet the standard; a written improvement plan follows
GOALS FROM LAST PERIOD
Goal 1: [goal as agreed]
Result: [what happened, with numbers and dates] Rating: [1-5]
Goal 2: [goal as agreed]
Result: [what happened, with numbers and dates] Rating: [1-5]
Goal 3: [goal as agreed]
Result: [what happened, with numbers and dates] Rating: [1-5]
COMPETENCIES (rate each; one dated example per rating)
Job knowledge and skills Rating: [1-5] Evidence: [example, date, link]
Quality of work Rating: [1-5] Evidence: [example, date, link]
Productivity and reliability Rating: [1-5] Evidence: [example, date, link]
Communication Rating: [1-5] Evidence: [example, date, link]
Collaboration Rating: [1-5] Evidence: [example, date, link]
Problem-solving and initiative Rating: [1-5] Evidence: [example, date, link]
[Role-specific competency] Rating: [1-5] Evidence: [example, date, link]
SELF-REVIEW (employee completes before the meeting)
What I am most proud of this period: [answer]
A challenge I faced and how I handled it: [answer]
Where I need support: [answer]
Goals I propose for next period: [answer]
MANAGER SUMMARY
Key strengths (2-3, each with an example): [answer]
Growth areas (1-2, each with an example): [answer]
Overall rating: [1-5] How it was reached: [weights or written rationale]
GOALS FOR NEXT PERIOD
Goal 1: [specific outcome] Measure: [metric and target] Check-in: [date]
Goal 2: [specific outcome] Measure: [metric and target] Check-in: [date]
Goal 3: [specific outcome] Measure: [metric and target] Check-in: [date]
DEVELOPMENT PLAN
Skill or behavior: [what to build] Action: [course, project, mentoring]
Support from manager: [time, budget, access] Due: [date]
COMMENTS AND SIGNATURES
Employee comments: [optional; attach a page if needed]
Employee signature / date: [signing confirms the review was discussed]
Manager signature / date: [signature]
Second-level or HR review / date: [if your policy requires it]
Keep the competency list short. Five to eight lines is enough for most roles; more than ten turns the review into a checklist, and managers start rating everything a 3.
Here is the same template filled in for a fictional customer support specialist at her mid-year review. Every rating points to a number, a date or a work sample.
EMPLOYEE REVIEW
Employee: Maya Torres (fictional) Job title: Customer Support Specialist
Department: Customer Support Reviewer: Daniel Okafor, Support Team Lead
Review type: mid-year
Review period: 2026-01-01 to 2026-06-30 Meeting date: 2026-07-09
GOALS FROM LAST PERIOD
Goal 1: Keep CSAT at or above 92% on handled tickets
Result: 94.1% across 1,184 rated tickets (team average 91.3%) Rating: 4
Goal 2: Cut first-response time on email tickets from 6h to under 4h
Result: 3h 40m median from April after inbox rules change Rating: 4
Goal 3: Publish 6 help-center articles for top ticket drivers
Result: 3 published, 2 in draft; refund article cut repeat tickets Rating: 2
COMPETENCIES (rate each; one dated example per rating)
Job knowledge and skills Rating: 4 Evidence: billing escalations 03-12
Quality of work Rating: 4 Evidence: 2 QA flags in 60 reviews
Productivity and reliability Rating: 3 Evidence: met queue targets 5 of 6 mo
Communication Rating: 4 Evidence: outage macro reused team-wide
Collaboration Rating: 5 Evidence: trained 2 new hires in May
Problem-solving and initiative Rating: 4 Evidence: proposed inbox rules, Mar
Writing for the help center Rating: 2 Evidence: 3 of 6 articles shipped
SELF-REVIEW (employee completes before the meeting)
What I am most proud of this period: onboarding Priya and Sam in May.
A challenge I faced and how I handled it: the March outage queue; I wrote a
shared macro and took the evening shift twice.
Where I need support: protected time for help-center writing.
Goals I propose for next period: finish the article backlog; learn Tier 2.
MANAGER SUMMARY
Key strengths: customer satisfaction above team average on high volume; the
inbox rules Maya proposed cut median first response by over 2 hours; new
hires reached full queue load one week early with her training.
Growth areas: help-center writing slipped when queues spiked; 3 of 6
articles shipped. The refund article alone cut repeat refund tickets 18%.
Overall rating: 4 (Exceeds) How it was reached: goals 50%, competencies 50%;
goals 3.33, competencies 3.71, weighted 3.52; team bands: 3.50-4.49 = 4.
GOALS FOR NEXT PERIOD
Goal 1: Ship the 3 remaining articles Measure: published Check-in: 08-15
Goal 2: Handle Tier 2 billing tickets Measure: 20/week, QA 90%+ Check-in: 09-30
Goal 3: Keep CSAT at or above 92% Measure: monthly CSAT Check-in: monthly
DEVELOPMENT PLAN
Skill or behavior: Tier 2 billing Action: shadow Tier 2 lead 2h/week in July
Support from manager: 3h/week blocked for writing Due: 2026-09-30
COMMENTS AND SIGNATURES
Employee comments: agree; asked to pair with a writer on the first article.
Employee signature / date: M. Torres 2026-07-09
Manager signature / date: D. Okafor 2026-07-09
What makes this example useful:
The core template works for every review. What changes is the period, the weight on goals versus behaviors, and who gives input.
| Review type | When to use it | What to change in the template |
|---|---|---|
| Annual review | Pay, promotion and long-term development decisions | Full year of goals; add a career section and a compensation note if pay is discussed. See the annual review template guide. |
| Mid-year review | Course correction halfway through the year | Rate progress, not final results; rewrite goals that no longer fit |
| Quarterly check-in | Fast-moving teams and short goal cycles | Drop the competency table to 3 lines; focus on goals, blockers and support |
| 30-60-90 day review | New hires and internal moves | Replace goals with onboarding milestones; rate learning speed and fit. See the 90-day review template. |
| Self-evaluation | Before any manager review | Give the employee the same form; they rate themselves and cite their own evidence |
| Peer review | Collaborative roles and cross-team work | Two or three questions on collaboration and communication; no overall rating |
| Manager (upward) review | Feedback on people managers from their reports | Rate clarity, support, feedback and fairness; keep responses anonymous |
| 360-degree review | Leadership roles and promotion cases | Combine manager, self, peer and direct report input; summarize themes, do not average raw scores |
| Performance improvement review | Sustained performance below the standard | Specific gaps, measurable targets, support and a short timeline. Use a performance improvement plan template. |
If you want ready-made forms from other providers to compare, see this list of free performance review templates.
Swap the role-specific competency and the goal measures. Keep the rest of the form the same so ratings stay comparable across teams.
| Role | Goal measures that work | Role-specific competency |
|---|---|---|
| Sales | Quota attainment, win rate, qualified pipeline created | Discovery and deal qualification |
| Customer support | CSAT, first-response time, resolution time, QA score | Written tone and de-escalation |
| Engineering | Delivery against estimates, defect escape rate, review turnaround | Code quality and technical design |
| Marketing | Pipeline sourced, conversion rates, launch dates hit | Message clarity and testing discipline |
| People managers | Team retention, goal completion across the team, upward review scores | Coaching and delegation |
Pick measures the employee can influence. A support specialist can control response time; they cannot control how many tickets arrive.
Use these to fill the form, prepare for the meeting, or build a self-evaluation. You do not need all of them; choose four to six per section.
Each comment below follows the same pattern: the behavior, an example, and the effect. Replace the bracketed parts with your own details. Generic praise ("great attitude") gives the employee nothing to repeat or fix.
The template gives you structure. These steps make the ratings consistent between managers and defensible later.

Write down which decisions the review will feed: development only, or also pay, promotion or an improvement plan. Tell employees before the cycle starts. A review that quietly decides pay but is presented as "just a development chat" destroys trust in the next one.
| Purpose | Cadence | Who takes part |
|---|---|---|
| Pay and promotion | Annual, with a mid-year check | Manager, self-review, calibration with peers' managers |
| Development | Quarterly or mid-year | Manager and employee, peer input optional |
| Onboarding | 30, 60 and 90 days | Manager, new hire, onboarding buddy |
| Leadership growth | Annual 360 | Manager, self, peers, direct reports |
A five-point scale only works when each level describes something you can observe. This is the idea behind a behaviorally anchored rating scale: each number is tied to a concrete behavior for that competency.
| Competency | 1 Below | 3 Meets | 5 Exceptional |
|---|---|---|---|
| Results | Misses deadlines; work often incomplete | Delivers agreed goals on time | Exceeds goals and improves how the team works |
| Communication | Updates are rare or unclear | Keeps people informed; decisions are written down | Others reuse their updates; resolves confusion across teams |
| Collaboration | Works in isolation; handovers are late | Shares work and helps when asked | Builds others' skills; teams seek them out |
Write levels 2 and 4 as "between" levels, or define them if your team argues about them. Share the scale with employees before the review period starts, not on review day.
Ratings built from memory favor the last six weeks. Keep a running note per report: wins, misses, feedback received, with a date and a link. Ten minutes after each one-on-one is enough. When you write the review, every rating should cite at least one of these notes.

Send the self-review section a week before the meeting. For 360 reviews, pick four to six raters who worked closely with the person, explain how answers will be used, and keep direct-report answers anonymous. When you summarize multi-source input, report themes ("three of four peers mentioned slow handovers") rather than averaging scores from people who saw different work.
Use the pattern from the comment examples above: behavior, example, effect, next step. Balance matters, but do not invent strengths to soften a hard message, and do not hide a real problem among praise. If something is serious enough to affect pay or employment, the employee should already have heard it before the review.
Decide the weights before the cycle, and show the math on the form.
| Component | Weight | Score | Weighted |
|---|---|---|---|
| Goals | 50% | 3.33 | 1.67 |
| Competencies | 50% | 3.71 | 1.86 |
| Overall | 100% | 3.52 |
Then convert the number to a band your company has defined:
| Band | Score range | Typical next step |
|---|---|---|
| 5 Exceptional | 4.50 and above | Promotion case, stretch scope, top of merit range |
| 4 Exceeds | 3.50 to 4.49 | Above-standard merit increase, new responsibility |
| 3 Meets | 2.50 to 3.49 | Standard merit increase, development goal |
| 2 Developing | 1.50 to 2.49 | Coaching plan with dated check-ins |
| 1 Below | Below 1.50 | Written performance improvement plan |
If a manager changes the calculated rating, require a written reason. Calibrate across managers before ratings are shared: managers compare ratings for similar roles and challenge outliers in both directions.

Share the written review a day before the meeting so the conversation is about the content, not reading. A 45 to 60 minute agenda works for most reviews:
When the employee disagrees, three short moves keep the meeting useful:
Within two days, send a written summary of decisions and goals. Hold the first check-in on the date you agreed. A review that is never mentioned again teaches the team that the form does not matter.
| Mistake | What it looks like | Fix |
|---|---|---|
| Recency bias | The last month decides the year's rating | Keep dated notes through the period; review them before writing |
| Halo or horns effect | One strong or weak trait colors every rating | Rate each competency on its own evidence |
| Leniency and central tendency | Everyone gets a 3 or 4 | Calibrate across managers; use behavior anchors |
| Rating personality | "Not a team player" | Name the behavior and its effect instead |
| Surprises in the review | First time the employee hears about a problem | Raise issues when they happen; the review only summarizes |
| No follow-up | Goals are agreed, then forgotten | Put check-in dates on calendars in the meeting |
Gallup research found that only 14% of employees strongly agree their performance reviews inspire them to improve. Most of the fixes above are about the same thing: frequent, specific conversations, with the formal review as a summary rather than a verdict.
| Format | Best for | Watch out for |
|---|---|---|
| Word or Google Docs | Narrative reviews, small teams, editing comments together | Version sprawl when files are emailed |
| Printed forms, signatures, the final record | Hard to edit; keep the editable source | |
| Excel or Google Sheets | Scoring many people at once, weighted calculations | Comments get cramped; access control on shared sheets |
| Shared workspace | Linking goals, notes and evidence through the year | Set access so only the employee, manager and HR can see each review |
Many teams use two formats: a shared workspace during the period and a signed PDF as the record of each review.
AFFiNE is a workspace for docs, whiteboards and databases. It is not an HR information system, and it does not calculate pay or handle approvals. What it does well for reviews is keeping the form, the running notes and the goals in one place.

Reviews contain sensitive personal data. Store them in a workspace that only the right people can open, and follow your company's rules on where personnel records may be kept. Browse the AFFiNE templates gallery for related meeting and planning templates.
In the United States, EEOC rules at 29 CFR 1602.14 require covered employers to keep personnel records, including records related to promotion, demotion, pay and termination, for at least one year from when the record was made or the action was taken, whichever is later. Records relevant to a discrimination charge must be kept until the matter is resolved. State law and other countries' rules may require longer periods or give employees the right to see their file.
Practical rules that help in any jurisdiction:
An employee review template should include employee and reviewer details, the review period, a defined rating scale, last period's goals with results, five to eight competencies with evidence, a self-review, a manager summary with an overall rating, next period's goals, a development plan and signatures.
A good employee review comment names a behavior, gives an example and states the effect. For example: "You trained two new hires in May, and both reached full workload a week earlier than our usual ramp." Avoid labels such as "great attitude" that do not point to anything the employee did.
Use the same rating scale with behavior anchors for comparable roles, cite dated evidence for every rating, read the employee's self-review first, separate behavior from personality, show how the overall rating was calculated and calibrate ratings across managers before sharing them.
Most companies hold a formal annual or mid-year review for pay and promotion decisions and add quarterly or monthly check-ins on goals. New hires usually get reviews at 30, 60 and 90 days. Faster-changing roles benefit from shorter cycles.
Plan 45 to 60 minutes for an annual or mid-year review and 20 to 30 minutes for a quarterly check-in. Share the written review a day before so the meeting is spent on discussion and next steps.
Policies vary, but a signature usually confirms that the review was discussed, not that the employee agrees with it. Give employees space to add their own comments, and note on the form what the signature means.
The template, example and comment bank were written by the AFFiNE content team. The example employee and her numbers are fictional. This guide has not been reviewed by an employment lawyer or a certified HR professional; check pay, promotion, termination and recordkeeping decisions with your HR or legal adviser.